Ensatina eschscholtzii (Gray,
1850) Ensatina
(Ensatina
eschscholtzii gallery)
Currently, the general consensus as to the genus
Ensatina is that it is comprised of one polytypic species, Ensatina
eschscholtzii. Most authors accept the "seven subspecies" classification
of E. eschscholtzii, however, more studies will likely divide E.
eschscholtzii into two or more species. In fact, the klauberi subspecies
is currently treated as a full species by some. Speculation also
surrounds the oregonensis subspecies, which is often regarded as a
morphotype. Traditionally, E. eschscholtzii has been treated as a
"ring species", whose subspecies form a ring around the Great
Central Valley of California, with intergrade zones occurring where the
subspecies meet, except in the case of the southern subspecies...
Introduction
Ensatina eschscholtzii are a glossy, sometimes rather colorful
species found throughout western U.S. and lower British Columbia. The body is
somewhat robust, with long limbs, and thick tails with a prominent
constriction near the base. It is at the constriction that the tail
autotomizes when necessary to distract potential predators.
Subspecies range in size from 2.95-6.10 inches in total length,
and increase in size from north to south, with the exception of the rather
small E. e. picta. Males can
be differentiated from females by their more truncated snouts, swollen
cloaca, and enlarged upper lip Stebbins, 2003). Males also possess longer, more slender
tails than females. Significance of size between males and females is
unknown. There are approximately seven recognized subspecies,
and several intergrade zones.
Although E. eschscholtzii is generally treated as a "ring
species", with seven subspecies, studies have shown limited gene
exchange between many of the subspecies, indicating the likelihood of
species level classification of some of some in the near
future. It is hypothesized that the genus Ensatina is comprised of two or more
species that form a superspecies complex. Another hypothesis states that
the Ensatina complex is a "double ring species", with two
zones where overlapping subspecies display little or no gene exchange (Petranka,
1998). However, for now, and until further data proves otherwise, E.
eschscholtzii will be treated as one, polytypic species, with the
traditional seven subspecies. In general, there are blotched subspecies
found in the southern and eastern sides of the Great Central Valley, while
the coastal and northwestern subspecies are un-blotched. The following briefly describes the different
subspecies:
Subspecies
E. e. eschscholtzii (Gray, 1850) Monterey Ensatina
The nominate form is reddish pink dorsally, with whitish-pink
undersides. The proximal portions of the limbs are light orangish-pink. The
sub- and super-ocular areas, and eyes
are darker than those of the similar looking
subspecies, E. e. xanthoptica. The upper eyelids are lighter than the dorsal color, and often have a pinkish hue. The tail may have light colored
blotching. E. e. eschscholtzii are found
from northern San Luis Obispo Co. south to extreme northern Baja
California, and easterly to Kitching Peak above Cabazon and to Sawmill
Canyon (Stebbins, 2003; Brown). E. e. eschscholtzii hybridizes with E. e.
xanthoptica and rarely with E. e. klauberi (= Ensatina klauberi)
in overlapping areas (Stebbins, 2003; Brown). Inland populations in San Bernardino and San Gabriel Mountains
are often spotted with dark blotches about the dorsum.

E. e. eschscholtzii, photos © Gary
Nafis, California
Reptiles and Amphibians
| more photos of Ensatina eschscholtzii
E. e. xanthoptica (Stebbins, 1949) Yellow Eyed
Ensatina
E. e. xanthoptica are dark to moderately dark brown dorsally, with
yellow-orange colored bellies. This subspecies possesses distinct yellow coloration about the
sub- and super-ocular areas, as well
as a distinct yellow patch in the eye. The yellow eye coloration, in addition to the brown dorsum
and lighter colored belly is thought to be mimicry of sympatric
Tarichids,
the toxic newts of the genus
Taricha.
Juveniles are darker colored dorsally, with bright yellow-orange
coloration at the bases of the limbs, and often a similar colored tail. This subspecies is found
from Sonoma Co., Calif. to Merced Co., and Santa Cruz Co (Stebbins,
2003). E. e.
xanthoptica hybridize with E. e. eschscholtzii where their
ranges overlap. Populations are also found on the inland side of the ring,
where they rarely hybridize with E. e. platensis.

E. e. xanthoptica, photos © Gary Nafis,
California
Reptiles and Amphibians
| more photos of Ensatina
eschscholtzii
E. e. oregonensis (Girard, 1856) Oregon Ensatina
In some texts this subspecies is only recognized as a morphotype, that is, a
morpholocially distinct group that may be out of synchrony with
molecular findings (Stebbins, 2003). This form is light to moderately dark
brown dorsally, with a lighter colored, speckled or mottled belly. Flecks of
white or pale orange are often found on the dorsum. The sides are orange
or yellow, sometimes with lighter colored mottling concentrated about
the costal grooves. Yellow-orange coloration is found on the proximal portions
of all four limbs. Petranka (1998) shows distribution from
southwestern Canada, south along the Washington and Oregon coasts, and into
northwestern California coastal areas. Stebbins (2003) has excluded the
California distribution, and instead provides an unknown intergrade range in
place. E. e. oregonensis is thought to intergrade with E. e.
eschscholtzii in the San Francisco Bay area, and with E. e.
platensis in the northern Sierra Foothills, however, the exact range
of the intergrade
zones are questionable.

E. e. oregonensis (left), and E. e.
oregonensis X platensis (right), photos © Gary Nafis,
California
Reptiles and Amphibians | more photos of Ensatina
eschscholtzii
E. e. picta (Girard, 1856) Painted Ensatina
This is a smaller subspecies, approximately 2/3 the size of the nominate
form (Stebbins, 2003). E. e. picta are light to dark brown dorsally, with black or
yellow-orange blotching that extends onto the tail, although some may lack any
blotching. In the intergrade zone with E. e. platensis, spot size is
diminished in a narrow zone, and from here forward, spot size increases into
the large, brightly colored blotches characteristic of E. e. platensis,
with some plain colored individuals dispersed about the entire intergrade
zone (Stebbins, 2003; Petranka, 1998; Brown). E. e. picta have a small range that includes extreme northwestern California, into
extreme southwestern Oregon. E. e. picta intergrade with E. e.
oregonensis in California.

E. e. picta, photos © Gary Nafis,
California
Reptiles and Amphibians
| more photos of Ensatina
eschscholtzii
E. e. platensis (Espada, 1875) Sierra Nevada Ensatina
This is a very colorful subspecies, usually blotched with bright orange,
reddish, or yellow about the head, body, limbs, and tail. Blotching varies
in size and abundance from small flecks, to nearly solid colored
individuals. The ventral surface is whitish-cream to pale gray
colored. Juveniles are darker colored, with reduced blotching
on the dorsal surface. Bright coloration is found on the proximal portions
of all four limbs. This subspecies is found throughout the Sierra Nevada foothills
of California, to the Greenhorn Mountains, southeast of Bakersfield (Stebbins,
2003; Brown). In the
north, E. e. platensis intergrades with E. e. oregonensis, and
in the south with E. e. croceater.

E. e. platensis (left), E. e.
platensis X croceater (right), photos © Gary Nafis,
California
Reptiles and Amphibians | more photos of Ensatina
eschscholtzii
E. e. croceater (Cope, 1867) Yellow Blotched Ensatina
This subspecies possesses blotching of large, yellow, orangish, or cream
colored markings about the dorsum, head, tail, and legs, on a black or
dark gray background. Spots are typically large, and either connected,
or clearly differentiated, as opposed to E. e. platensis, which
may appear densely mottled with varying sized spots. The ventral surface
is pale cream colored to light gray. Bright coloration is found on the
proximal portions of all four limbs E. e. croceater are found in the Tehachapi Mts.,
Pinos, vicinity of Fort Tejon, and the Frazier-Alamo Mt. area,
California (Stebbins, 2003). Intergrades of E. e. croceater and E.
e. platensis are occur in the southern range of E. e. platensis
and the northern range of E. e. croceater. This subspecies also
intergrades with E. e. klauberi.

E. e. croceater (left), E. e.
platensis X croceater (right), photos © Gary Nafis,
California
Reptiles and Amphibians | more photos of Ensatina
eschscholtzii
E. e. klauberi (Dunn, 1929) Large Blotched Ensatina
In some texts, E. e. klauberi is considered a full species, Ensatina
klauberi. Like E. e. croceater, E. e. klauberi possess
large blotches of orange, white, or yellow, over a black background. The
spots are often connected, and create diagonal, or transverse bands
about the dorsum and tail (Petranka, 1998). The ventral surface is dark gray.
Bright coloration is found on the proximal portions of all four limbs. E.
e. klauberi intergrade with E. e. croceater in the San
Bernardino Mountains, and rarely with E. e. eschscholtzii in southern
ranges.

E. e. klauberi, photos © Gary Nafis,
California
Reptiles and Amphibians | more photos of Ensatina
eschscholtzii
Distribution & Integration Patterns
Ensatina eschscholtzii is regarded as a "ring species",
whose subspecies form a ring of distribution around the Great Central
Valley of California. The known zones of intergration are narrow at many
points, and broader at others. Starting from the nominate form and working
northerly, E. e. eschscholtzii are found in coastal areas of
southern California north to Monterey Bay, where it intergrades into E.
e. xanthoptica. E. e. xanthoptica is found in the San
Francisco Bay, and intergrades with E. e. oregonensis around the
Santa Rosa area (Brown). E. e. oregonensis is thought to occur from Santa
Rosa, north into Oregon, Washington, and British Columbia, although
Stebbins (2003) regards E. e. oregonensis's California range as
an undefined zone, possibly an intergrade zone. E. e. oregonensis
also intergrades
with E. e. picta in extreme northwestern California. Looping
around the northern Central Valley, E. e. oregonensis intergrades
into E. e. platensis in the northern Sierra Nevada area. E. e.
platensis are found on the inland side of the distribution ring,
from the Sierra Nevada to the Greenhorn Mountains, just southeast of
Bakersfield, where intergration with E. e. croceater occurs
(Brown). Interestingly, there are populations of E. e. xanthoptica
found on the inland side of the ring as well, where they are now
isolated from populations on the coastal side of the ring, and which rarely intergrade with E.
e. platensis. E. e. xanthoptica are thought to have
crossed the California Valley during a time when climatic
conditions were more hospitable (Petranka, 1998). E. e.
croceater are found in the Tehachapi Mountains south of Bakersfield,
where a gap is formed between it and the next populations of E.
eschscholtzii, the croceater-klauberi intergrades (Brown). Further south is E. e. klauberi, found east and northeast
of San Diego. E.
e. klauberi does hybridize with E. e. eschscholtzii in at
least three
known sites, but only
coexists in other localities. In fact, electrophoritic separations of
selected enzymes and DNA patterns have proven E. e. klauberi is a
separate species by definition (Brown). In the near
future, it is likely that molecular data will divide E. eschscholtzii
into
two or more species. For now, and until present
studies are completed, Ensatina eschscholtzii is regarded as a
polytypic species; a semispecies complex that portrays a typical example of the
Darwinian gradualism, where multiple micro-mutations have lead to the
formation of several subspecies/species (Brown).
Habits & Habitats
The range of E.
eschscholtzii is large, and includes a variety of habitats. In the north,
forest clearings, and wooded areas are favored, while the southern populations
may be found in north-facing slopes of canyons, oak woodland, mixed grassland,
and chaparral (Stebbins, 2003). In the more arid southern regions, Ensatina are
also found in close vicinity to streams and ponds, where the soil is moist.
Populations in the northern climate occupy a wider variety of
habitats, with or without nearby water sources. In extreme heat or cold, E.
eschscholtzii will seek out retreats under rotting logs, within rotting
root channels, or underground channels excavated by rodents.Adults and
juveniles are most active during wet weather, when they can be found on the
surface in abundance. Adults go back into hiding during the
egg laying period, but juveniles may remain on the
surface until the onset of drier, warmer weather (Petranka, 1998). Ensatina do not create their
burrows, but occupy abandoned holes, root channels, and other micro-channels
that allow them to escape the dry surface. Adults may reside as deep as 90 cm
below the surface during the summer. At the time of emergence, in autumn, adults
and juveniles may be depleted of food reserves after their summer aestivation. Males
are territorial outside of the breeding season, and do not tolerate other males
within their summer residences. Females are less territorial than males.
Individuals are thought to mark their territory with feces or chemical
secretions.
 Humboldt
Co., habitat of E. e. oregonensis. Photo
© Gary Nafis,
California
Reptiles and Amphibians
Lifecycle
Breeding commences about the beginning of Autumn, and ceases at the onset of
warming temperatures, usually in late March. One known exception is E. e.
platensis, which is active as late as April and May (Petranka, 1989). It is thought that
other inland subspecies may also breed later in the season than coastal
subspecies.
Courtship consists of the male creeping up to the female, and nudging the
sides of her head, face, and throat with his head and neck. The male then moves
into a position such that his hip region is just under the females chin. The
male will rub the hip region about the females throat by rotating hip
movements. The male will then attempt to lead the female off, while keeping the back
in an arched position. A stimulated female will press her throat against the
males hip region, and follow his lead, while straddling his tail. This stage of
courtship may last for several hours (Petranka, 1998).
After a suitable time, the male stops and deposits a spermatophore onto the substrate, while the female strokes his sacral (hip) region with her throat.
After a short while, the female lifts her head, and the two move forward until
the spermatophore is aligned with the females vent. The female collects the
spermatophore by squatting down onto it. At the same time, the male moves back a
bit, positions his tail over the females back, and flicks it to and forth. At
this point, courtship has ended, however, a pair may begin courting again a few
moments later (Petranka, 1998).
Females of southern and central populations deposit eggs in late spring,
while northern coastal and higher elevation Sierra Nevada populations deposit in
early summer. Oviposition requires a day, during which the female may lay on her
side or back (Petranka, 1998). Five to twenty-five eggs are deposited in
disconnected clumps, in moist hiding spots, typically under logs, moss-mats, or
underground. Late semester embryos possess leaf-like, vascularized gills. Clutch
size is proportional to the females size, and the incubation period lasts
anywhere from 4-5 months (Petranka, 1998). Females will remain and guard their
clutches to hatching.
Juveniles grow quickly for the first few years of life, and slow down
drastically as they near sexual maturity.

E. e. oregonensis, photos © Suzanne L. Collins,
Center for North American
Herpetology |
more photos of Ensatina
eschscholtzii
Defense Method
Ensatina have a distinct defense posture, which consists of raising the body high off the ground, with the back arched
downward, and the tail arched upward. The tail may be lashed about, as
milky secretions are produced from it and from glands behind the
head.
If further provoked, Ensatina may autotomize their writhing tails, in
an attempt to distract a potential predator. This may give the salamander
a moment to sneak away. The tail is constricted at the base, which marks
the spot of separation. Tail regeneration may take up to two years. Tail
autotomization may cause the salamander hardship in the future, especially
during aestivation, as it is
an important storage reserve.
The mottled coloration and pattern of some is
thought to be a form of cryptic coloration related to soil color. The
mottled forms typically possess bright coloration specifically on the
proximal portions of the limbs and the dorsum, which may have the effect of breaking up the
salamanders silhouette against certain backgrounds.
Juveniles and adults of the non-blotched forms often possess the same coloration about the proximal areas of
the limbs.
As
mentioned earlier, some coastal populations are thought to be mimics of toxic newts of the
genus
Taricha. This
is especially noticeable in E. e. xanthoptica, which possess light
yellowish coloration about the snout, subocular, and superocular areas, as
well as a distinct yellow patch in the eye. This yellow coloration, in addition
to the dark to medium brown dorsum, is remarkably similar to some
Tarichids.

E. e. platensis defense posture, photo © Gary Nafis,
California
Reptiles and Amphibians | more photos of Ensatina
eschscholtzii

E. e. eschscholtzii with noxious
secretions, photo © Gary Nafis,
California
Reptiles and Amphibians | more photos of Ensatina
eschscholtzii
References
Petranka, James W. Salamanders of the United States and Canada. Smithsonian Institution Press, 1998.
Stebbins, Robert C. Western Reptiles and Amphibians (third edition). Houghton Mifflin Company, 2003.
Brown, Chuck. Ensatina eschscholtzi Speciation in Progress: A Classic
Example of Darwinian Evolution. Charles W. Brown, PhD, Santa Rosa Junior
College.
http://www.santarosa.edu/lifesciences2/ensatina2.htm
(Accessed: 2004).
Center for North American Herpetology. (2003).
http://www.cnah.org/
(Accessed: 2000).
Nafis, Gary. Ensatina eschscholtzii oregonensis (database entry). California
Reptiles & Amphibians.
http://www.californiaherps.com/salamanders/pages/e.e.oregonensis.html
(Accessed: 2004).
Nature Serve Explorer (Database). Nature Serve.
http://www.natureserve.org/explorer/index.htm
(Accessed: 2000-2003).
|